Blog Article
BACK

Staff Augmentation versus Turnkey Project Delivery

Avatar
Artur Serdiuk
Marketing Manager

A big fan of sports and marketing data.

Картинка статьи

Outsourcing remains an excellent way of implementing projects in companies across the planet. Cost-savings, a better competitive advantage, increased productivity, and reduced time of project implementation are some of the benefits that make this approach ideal for businesses. 

That said, when it comes to outsourcing, the success a company achieves on a project depends on the choice of engagement model to implement. In this article, we will tell you about two engagement models in outsourcing, staff augmentation (aka outstaffing), and turnkey projects (managed projects or time and materials (T&M) and fixed-price projects). We will explain each model in-depth to help you understand the differences, and, thus, help you choose the one that’s suitable for your situation. 

Staff Augmentation (aka Outstaffing)

Staff augmentation is an outsourcing approach that is used to staff a venture and address company goals. It involves the use of necessary technical resources, typically offshore, recruited as overseas development extensions of in-house teams on fixed or flexible terms. 

In this approach, the hiring company (staff augmentation provider) takes care of screening, vetting, hiring, and retaining specialists added to a client-tailored team. Then, if any skills gaps are identified at a specific phase of the project, qualified personnel are recruited on a short- or long-term basis as ad-hoc talent.

Types of Projects Staff Augmentation Is Best Suited For

Staff augmentation is well-suited for these types of projects:

  • Short-term: Businesses usually turn to this solution during their peak seasons, when a project phase comes with many tasks, and the in-house team cannot cope effectively. It is also an option when an in-house professional is sick or on a break.  
  • Long-term: If a company has a lengthier and more complicated project and does not have an expert with a specific skill internally, staff augmentation can come in handy.  

Where Does Project Management Reside: On Client or Vendor’s Side?

With staff augmentation, the project resides on the client’s side. More specifically, the company seeking staff augmentation will retain control of the project from start to completion. It means essential functions such as project management and technical leadership are strictly executed in-house. That said, from time to time, the business would have to assess its employees and find any necessary supporting skills to help specific initiatives. 

Pricing Structure

By implementing staff augmentation, a business will enjoy a more effective budgeting process. It is because all the costs of recruitment are factored in when it comes to the total cost of the vendor. Most of the time, companies outsource their projects to locations that will see them enjoy cost-savings. As such, for companies in the US, UK, or other developed regions, Eastern Europe countries, such as Ukraine, make an excellent outsourcing destination due to their considerably lower rates. In this case, if you were to outsource to Ukraine, you will find that the prices are two to three times lower than in North America or Israel.

Average Time to Hire/Onboard the Team

Unlike in Western countries, the recruitment cycles in locations, such as Ukraine, are much shorter. Why so? Such destinations have a large pool of readily available information technology experts, cutting back on time needed to find them. In Ukraine, for instance, the hiring cycle lasts for only about one to three weeks. 

Pros and Cons of Staff Augmentation

The benefits of staff augmentation are:

  • Sustained control over the team: If you need to manage your staff carefully during a project, this is the strategy to implement.
  • Maximum use of existing resources: With staff augmentation, companies take full advantage of both internal and external resources.
  • It avails specialist expertise: Staff replenishment helps companies to fill gaps in specialist skills.
  • Cuts costs of acquiring skills: This approach helps businesses to avoid investing in internal skill development. 

When it comes to disadvantages, perhaps the most renowned is low budget control. For this reason, if you get an unreliable vendor and they inflate their price, you will end up spending more. 

Turnkey or Managed Projects

One method of outsourcing is to hire a contractor to design, manufacture, and construct a product for you. This type of engagement model is referred to as a turnkey contract. In this case, you give the contractor the requirements for the software you want. Then the contractor procures all the material needed, builds or assembles the product, and transfers its ownership to you once done. 

Unlike staff augmentation where control of the outsourced team resides in-house, turnkey contracts typically include a dedicated project manager who controls the development process and manages the team. Thus, turnkey projects are also called managed projects. As with any other type of contract, a service-level agreement specifying the expected quality of the product and the responsibility for you, and the service provider should be drawn up. 

Projects Best-Suited for This Model

The turnkey engagement model is best suited for small projects that typically have short construction times and limited budgets. In this case, you deal with one offshore contractor for everything, and your product is delivered to you at a fixed date and rate. It is also a good option if you or members of your staff lack the technical expertise to manage/ control the project. That’s because the contractor handles everything for you. 

Project Management in This Type of Model

What makes turnkey projects unique is how they are managed. Rather than having an internal project supervisor to manage and oversee the team, turnkey projects come with a PM. The outsourced team, therefore, includes a project manager who controls the software development process and ensures delivery within the agreed-upon period. The vendor takes care of everything from designing, procurement of necessary materials, development, and commissioning. Ownership is then transferred to you once the product is ready for operation. 

Pricing for Turnkey Projects

A turnkey engagement model can assume either of these two pricing structures: 

  • Fixed-price

Fixed-price refers to a type of contract where the service provider completed the project at an agreed-upon amount. This pricing model works well for projects with highly predictable requirements and rates, and as a result, the cost is relatively constant. As the client, you give your vision for your product while the contractor makes sure the desired results are achieved. The full value of the contract is specified at the time it is awarding to the service provider. 

  • Time and materials (T&M)

This contract bills the client based on the cost of materials used to develop the software and the number of hours spent on the development process. Payment for labor is based on the going hourly rate. This model is highly flexible and allows for product scope modification during development. The contract’s full value is unknown at the time of awarding. T&M can, therefore, grow in value within the contract’s operation. 

Onboarding Timeline

Hiring a permanent software development team can take up to a couple of months. However, outsourcing reduces the time and cost to hire. In the turnkey engagement model, the client is not directly involved in the selection and hiring of individual team members. The vendor provides a team and project manager. Your job is to share your requirements, expectations, and goals, and in turn, the contractor gives you a proposal. Once you approve it, the job begins. This process can take about 1-2 weeks. 

Pros & Cons of Turnkey Engagement Model

So, what are the benefits and disadvantages of this type of outsourcing? 

Pros

  • Full responsibility for the project lies with the contractor
  • Involves less management work
  • Ensures error-free commissioning
  • Payment based on results
  • The vendor is responsible for all risks
  • Lower cost overruns (fixed-price model)

Cons

  • Limited client involvement and control of the project
  • Costs may exceed your budget (T&M model)
  • Integration of the project with internal processes may be problematic

Final Thoughts

In recent years, outsourcing has expanded to include multiple options. Now, you can choose an engagement model based on the type of project you are looking to develop, your budget, timeline, etc. Whether you go for staff augmentation or turnkey, remember to hire a reputable service provider.

Do you need help building a dedicated/extended Team or getting ad-hoc resources for your software development project fast and cost-effectively?